Friday, July 30, 2010


I read a great article from Forbes Magazine about piano lessons and being smart. Please follow this link and review this valuable information.

Thursday, July 1, 2010


      There is a long standing debate among piano students and teachers about whether or not a piano player should play with curved fingers or flat fingers.  There are many famous piano performers who play with flat fingers and many who claim that curved fingers are a must. I have done a little research and come up with the following conclusions:

     I think that there is a reason that our fingers are shaped the way they are. If I play with flat fingers, I am not using the natural shape of my fingers.  It makes sense to me to choose a finger shape that is natural. Flat is not a natural shape for fingers.

     I like to tell piano students about engineering students who build bridges made out of balsa wood. They build many bridges of different shapes- flat, round, arched, and square. Then they put force on the bridges. The bridge that holds the most bricks without breaking wins a prize. Go to and note the shape of the bridge that holds the current record. It is exactly the same shape as a finger. I think that shape of a curved finger allows you to put more weight into your playing.  It creates a more powerful sound. 

     I have noticed that those who play with curved fingers are able to play faster. When you curve your fingers, your hand and wrist are naturally higher. If you are playing a scale that requires you to cross your fingers under, there is more room for you to move under your hand if your wrist is a bit higher.

     I like to send my students to take lessons from my friend, Marilyn.  Marilyn has a degree in music pedagogy.  She teaches with the curved finger method.  On line research notes that most piano students and teachers are using this method.

     When a student is playing at a high level, they may learn that changing the curve of your fingers, can also change the sound.  Using more of the pad of your finger and lengthening your finger when you play, softens the sound.  A curved finger gives a stronger, firmer sound.

     If a student learns to play with flat fingers and they get to the point in their study that they need a curved position, it is very difficult for a student to change from flat to curved.  It is easy for a student to change from a curved hand position to a flat position.  I think this is because if you play flat-fingered, you have not exercised and strengthened the finger muscles you need to play the piano in a curved position.  Curved fingers have strong muscles that can stretch and straighten- flat or curved- without any problem.  

   Here is a description and picture of a natural curved hand: 

    1.Slightly indented wrist in neutral position.

    2.Top knuckles highest part of hand allowing full finger movement.

    3.Curved fingers position allows for greater piano proficiency and 50% reduction in force over extended finger position.

    4.Wrist position indicates that the elbow is away from the body, creating natural position for the wrist.

    5-Play without wrists bouncing up and down.

     One of the most difficult things a piano teacher needs to do is to get students to curve their fingers.  I remember my piano teacher used a ruler.  She taped the back of my hand with the ruler whenever I forgot to curve.  I learned to curve very quickly. 
     I did not like the ruler so I have another, nicer way to teach students how to curve.  I call it 'piano physical therapy'.   If I have a student who can't hold their finger in a curved position, I hold their knuckles for them while they play.  This invasion of personal space also encourages students to curve on their own and it is less painful than a ruler. 
     I also find that positive reinforcement and bribery helps students to curve their fingers. My friend, Marilyn, told me that constant reminders about curving also help.  As a parent practices with achild, they should encourage them to curve their fingers as much as possible.

Total Pageviews